The travesty of Chinese Taipei

Flag of Chinese Taipei

Over the last week chances are good you’ve seen at least some of the Olympic Games.  I was watching a few days ago when I saw a flag for “Chinese Taipei” on the screen.  Then I heard an announcer on the CBC refer to this nation that I had not heard of.  There are more than two hundred nations participating in these games; I can’t claim to have heard of all of them.

So, what’s the deal with Chinese Taipei?  Well, it turns out, Chinese Taipei is really the nation we know of as Taiwan.  Riddle solved?  Not quite… it turns out Taiwan isn’t really a nation either.  You’re probably thinking ‘WHAT!?’  Some of the best stuff is made in Taiwan. The place we know of as Taiwan actually calls itself the Republic of China (ROC).  How can there be two Chinas?  The China that’s playing host to the 2008 Olympic Games officially refers to itself as the People’s Republic of China (PRC).

So there’s a nomenclature issue… where’s the travesty here?  And why does their flag have the Olympic Rings on it?  Well, it’s complicated.  As an outsider it appears to involve a substantial amount of pig-headedness.  There are two criteria for nationhood, which are critical to this issue:

  1. Self-declaration of nationhood
  2. Recognition of nationhood from other nations

When PRC went communist, ROC claimed sovereignty over China, even though they no longer had any influence over it.  ROC assumed China’s seat at the United Nations on the security council, as it was recognized by most of the world as representing China.  Then in the 1970s there was a shift; countries began shifting their recognition to PRC instead of ROC.  In a highly controversial move that was possibly illegal under the charter of the United Nations, the Republic of China was expelled from the United Nations in 1971 in favour of the People’s Republic of China under UN General Assembly resolution 2758.

Here’s the rub:  with this move, the “United” Nations effectively sanctions the so-called One China policy in which China claims sovereignty over Hong Kong, Tibet and Macau.  Behaviour like that is fairly predictable when it’s coming from China, but the UN?

Basically, taiwan got fucked by the UN.  Even thirty years later, they are still denied entry into the United Nations.

The result is that Taiwan is not officially recognized.  China refuses to allow them to represent themselves as Taiwan or the Republic of China, as it is in contravention to their One China policy.  And so the name Chinese Taipei is the compromise that allows Taiwan to participate internationally, such as in the Olympic Games.

Fucking unfair, if you ask me.

One Response to The travesty of Chinese Taipei

  1. The problem is that Taiwan (the Republic of China) is still regarded as a PROVINCE of China. We may therefore not enter the UN as a country. Of course, this should means that China’s UN delegation includes representatives of Taiwan, but that is the same as agreeing to the ridiculous notion that Taiwan IS a part of China.

    So, in order to be a nation, we (Taiwan) must first declare ‘independence.

    IF we declare independence, China will attack us (with some or all of the 700 missiles aimed at Taiwan).

    Also, if we declare independence, the USA will NOT back us up, because that is stipulated in the USA’s ‘Taiwan relations act’. This act was developed at a time when the USA still needed Taiwan as a cheap source of manufacturing, and we were a buffer zone with a US military presence on our island, in case China decided to go rogue.

    China has now taken over the role as the main manufacturer to the world, so really the USA does not need us.

    SO here is the catch..we can’t be nation, because the world won’t back us up, because no one has the balls to stand up to China’s arrogance. That’s why the Tibet problem has still not been resolved (in favor of the Tibetans), and that’s why Taiwan will continue to be Chinese-Taipei in all world sporting events.

    Can it be solved? Only if the wold decides that Taiwan has got the right to officially declare their independence form China.

    Fucking unfair? Completely!!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: